Liquidcross (talk | contribs) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
:The Tomb discrepancy is clearly due to continuity drift, as the finale had not yet been written when "[[Home, Part II]]" was penned. It remains unexplained who created or altered the star map to show the stars of our Earth as, as Grazier points out, it cannot have been the tribes of Kobol who did so. There is, however, nothing in the show that directly contradicts the possibility of some unknown agency being able to do this. | :The Tomb discrepancy is clearly due to continuity drift, as the finale had not yet been written when "[[Home, Part II]]" was penned. It remains unexplained who created or altered the star map to show the stars of our Earth as, as Grazier points out, it cannot have been the tribes of Kobol who did so. There is, however, nothing in the show that directly contradicts the possibility of some unknown agency being able to do this. | ||
:In addition, [[Gaeta]] comments in "[[Revelations]]" that the constellations seen from orbit of the Earth they'd just found match those seen in the Tomb of Athena. This | :In addition, [[Gaeta]] comments in "[[Revelations]]" that the constellations seen from orbit of the Earth they'd just found match those seen in the Tomb of Athena. This means either that the two Earths were close enough that constellations looked similar (and did not change over 150,000 years) or that the star patterns as seen from the two planets in different parts of the galaxy and different eras were coincidentally similar. | ||
== References == | == References == | ||
Revision as of 19:24, 2 March 2010
- For other uses of this name in Battlestar Galactica, see Athena.
The Tomb of Athena is presumably the final resting place of Athena, Lord of Kobol after her grief-stricken plunge from the Gates of Hera. It is unclear who interred her, since her death apparently took place after the exodus of the thirteen tribes from Kobol.
The tomb is located in the northern hemisphere, a few days hike from the Galleon Meadow, near the Gates of Hera, to the west of the ruins of the City of the Gods. According to the Sacred Scrolls, the tomb could only be opened with the Arrow of Apollo.
The Arrow is not a key to the tomb's actual door, however. While the exterior door to the tomb can be opened by brute force, the Arrow is required for something else. The tomb contains twelve stone sarcophagi arranged in a circle, each with ancient statues representing one of the Twelve Tribes which went on to found the Twelve Colonies. Picon was represented by a fish; Caprica, a goat; Sagittaron, an archer, and so on.
Kara Thrace places the Arrow in the bow of the Archer of Sagittaron. Immediately the Tomb's entrance closes, leaving those in the Tomb in darkness. After a few seconds, they find themselves in a grassy field at nighttime surrounded by twelve megalithic slabs[1], either physically transported or immersed in a very sophisticated hologram.
On each column is the ancient symbol of a colony as used on their respective old Colonial flags. Roslin notes that the symbols were used back when the ancient names of the Colonies were used: Aries instead of Aerelon, Taurus for Tauron, Gemini for Gemenon, and so on.
Above the group, the night sky shows constellations, each representing a colony. In fact, Thrace realizes that, according to the scriptures, that they were all standing on a representation of Earth, seeing what their comrades on Earth would see. The map information, however, was incomplete without one more stellar reference that Lee Adama finds in the Scorpius constellation: the Lagoon Nebula, an object visible on Earth and known as well to the Twelve Colonies. Lee Adama deduces that as they approached this point, the ship would be able to further define their position to Earth. Commander Adama notes that the nebula was "a long way away from here" (Home, Part II).
The group is not shown leaving the hologram or the Tomb. It can presumed that the group walks beyond the stones and the image fades to their actual location in the Tomb, then reopens the entrance - either by forcing it open once again or retrieving the Arrow - and exits.
Notes[edit]
- Adama notes that the Lagoon Nebula is known to the Colonials as "astro-body M8". This notation is the same one used for the nebula in the Messier catalogue, devised in 1774 by astronomer Charles Messier. The nebula, in reality, appears as a gray object in the sky with binoculars or telescope. It would not be as vivid or large in the sky by the naked eye as it was shown in the group's vision. The object is 5,200 light years from Earth, lies in the constellation of Sagittarius, not Scorpius, a mistake which has been admitted by the writers.
- The producers have acknowledged[2] that the twelve constellations of the Zodiac are never actually all visible at once in the night sky, but rather rotate around the north star throughout the night. The constellations were displayed as in the hologram for dramatic and informative purposes.
- While far longer a story arc, the events in finding and using the resources within the Tomb of Athena, a Lord of Kobol, is similar to the story line of an Original Series episode that also searches for the location of Earth from a tomb on a Kobol that was more reminiscent of Egyptian history than the quasi-Celtic, quasi-Greek appearances seen in the Re-imagined Series episode.
- The events of "Daybreak, Part II" have called into question how the holographic information within the Tomb shown in "Home, Part II" can exist. The Tomb clearly shows constellations as viewed from our Earth during modern times, but the Lords of Kobol wouldn't have known about it, the Thirteenth Tribe went to a different Earth, and Kara Thrace led the Fleet to our Earth 150,000 years ago (the constellations wouldn't have looked as they did in the Tomb, due to stellar drift). Kevin Grazier, BSG science advisor, considered the Tomb problem one of his biggest regrets from working on the show (full interview here, emphasis added):
- Is there anything you wish you could change?
- Grazier: There’s two. There’s one that I recognized too late. That was when the explosion in "Water" blew out the side of the [Galactica] and we have a big venting of water. [Galactica] was connected to the Virgon Express. That would have imparted a pretty healthy delta v [change in velocity], meaning it would have yanked the Virgon Express with [the Galactica] and probably broken the water lines. I didn’t think of that until too late, and I called and said “hang on!” and they said “that ship’s sailed, sorry.” That was the second episode and I was a baby science advisor then. The other one is I wish I would have been more insistent with the constellations in Home, Part II. Because when you start thinking about those constellations, who put them there? Wasn’t the Kobolians. Those aren’t seen from the original Earth, so where did those constellations come from?
- Those constellations were a big part of why was I sure the show had to be set in the future!
- Grazier: Right. I wish I had been more insistent on “we really need to rethink this.”
- The Tomb discrepancy is clearly due to continuity drift, as the finale had not yet been written when "Home, Part II" was penned. It remains unexplained who created or altered the star map to show the stars of our Earth as, as Grazier points out, it cannot have been the tribes of Kobol who did so. There is, however, nothing in the show that directly contradicts the possibility of some unknown agency being able to do this.
- In addition, Gaeta comments in "Revelations" that the constellations seen from orbit of the Earth they'd just found match those seen in the Tomb of Athena. This means either that the two Earths were close enough that constellations looked similar (and did not change over 150,000 years) or that the star patterns as seen from the two planets in different parts of the galaxy and different eras were coincidentally similar.
References[edit]
- ↑ The slabs are similar in appearance to those of the ancient Earth structure of Stonehenge.
- ↑ Podcast: Home, Part II , Act 4.