Title
Confusion! Episode 417 is Someone to Watch Over Me. Episode 416 is Deadlock according to producer Mark Verheiden.--Werthead 19:40, 18 September 2008 (UTC)
- I'll change it. And the admins always watch the recent changes. So you don't have to post stuff like this on all episode pages :) -- Serenity 21:04, 18 September 2008 (UTC)
- Noted. Galactica Sitrep also has a full list for all the writers and directors as well.--Werthead 12:19, 20 September 2008 (UTC)
Gaeta
Gaeta was executed in Blood on the Scales, yet he is listed as guest in this episode. Do we have a definite source for this?
- Just because he's dead, doesn't mean he can't return as a hallucination, or flashback, or dream, or vision etc, like Elosha, Adama's wife, Ellen Tigh (but that was before we found out she was a Cylon though). -- Matthew R Dunn 12:37, 15 February 2009 (UTC)
- PS, after looking through the page history, this is the source. -- Matthew R Dunn 12:40, 15 February 2009 (UTC)
- after airing, i didn't see Gaeta. did i miss him?—The preceding unsigned comment was added by Erifneerg (talk • contribs).
Nope. Didn't see him in any incarnation at all. I think it was just disinformation to throw off spoilers. Nothing more. --Mars 06:55, 1 March 2009 (UTC)
Projections
Now that we are aware Cylons can project non-existent people, do these "imaginary people" get their own article, or a new page be made for all projections? -Federationrulz 17:05, 28 February 2009 (UTC)
- Well, there is a page on Projection, it should probably be included there. -- Noneofyourbusiness 17:07, 28 February 2009 (UTC)
Boomer's motivations
I think it's really premature to state so conclusively that Boomer's kidnapping of Hera was ordered or orchestrated by Cavil. If the upcoming episodes confirm that, okay, but right now, it is only speculation. Just because Roslin says it doesn't mean it's true.
My impression is that Boomer's actions were more selfish than that. The rebels want to kill her as a traitor, and if Cavil DIDN'T authorize her freeing Ellen Tigh, Cavil is not going to be happy to see her again, either. Hera is the one thing that both sides potentially want, and thus a lever Boomer can use to save her own ass.
Unless the next episode sheds more light on this, I think it's more appropriate to frame that point as a question, e.g., "Did Cavil orchestrate Boomer's 'rescue' of Ellen in order to get his hands on Hera?"
--argentla 18:59, 28 February 2009 (UTC)
Timeline?
Currently there is a note that:
"Weeks have passed since the end of the mutiny, as evidenced by Cottle's comment about how long Anders' EKG readings have remained steady."
Cottle's comment is about Ander's "unprecidented, and frankly bizare" readings which "haven't changed in weeks", which occured at the end of episode 16, but later the comment is made that Thigh's "just lost his child", which happend arround the same time.
Is this a contuinuity contradiction or am I missing something?
The Piano Player
Although it's quite possible the piano player is Starbuck's father, we don't know this for certain. And this show is known for sending out false signals. (Exhibit A: Tigh being a Cylon). I reworded it slightly, but I would recommend we hold off making such an absolute statement until it's confirmed in one of the remaining episodes. It could be just as possible that Starbuck was projecting. 23skidoo 15:48, 1 March 2009 (UTC)
- RDM, Bear McCreary and the writers have all confirmed that Slick is indeed a vision of Kara's father. And how is Tigh being a Cylon a false signal? Ausir 16:06, 1 March 2009 (UTC)
Kara Thrace/Father
Just a hunch.. there was talk that the #7 Cylon (Daniel) was a musician or artsy kinda guy. Kara's apparent father is a musician... had to leave his wife and Kara... (his death, by the cavil's).
My Theory ... Kara is an offspring of a Cylon... could explain her resurecction, father, mysterious knowledge of the music... and her connection to final 5/Hera.
I THINK IM ONTO SOMETHING!!!
- Welcome to the other side of the looking glass! It would also explain her tendancy to draw things that she has never actually seen...another talent she shares with Hera. --Xenophon10k 20:46, 2 March 2009 (UTC)
The Dying Galactica
Although I obviously can't say it with 100% certainty, I think it's a foregone conclusion at this point that the "dying leader" mentioned in the Pythian texts is the Galactica herself. The last few episodes have gone out of their way to stress the point that Galactica is dying, and rather rapidly dying at that. Tyrol states she only has a few jumps left in her even with the help of the Cylon goop. The teaser for next week essentially shows Adama writing off the old girl. I get the feeling the call for "abandon ship" can't be far behind with only four episodes to go. I don't think Roslin is the "dying leader" for one simple reason: it's too obvious. RDM has a propensity for giving us false "obvious" answers in the past. I think it can't be Roslin (despite her collapse) simply because that's too tidy of an answer.