Colonial Day

Overview

Colonial Day is due, and Roslin is using it to institute an interim Quorum of Twelve; then Tom Zarek, duly selected as the representative of Sagittaron, stands for the post of Vice President, a position Roslin is determined he will not hold

Summary

Colonial Day - the anniversary of the signing of the Articles of Colonisation is due
Roslin has chosen it to unveil a new Quorum of Twelve
However, a crisis erupts when terrorist/criminal Tom Zarek is selected to represent Sagittaron – and he accepts
As the Quorum is convened, Zarek increases the crisis by insisting that the vacant post of Vice President is filled, in case anything should happen to Roslin – a move that is surprisingly seconded by Gaius Baltar – Tom Zarek is thereupon nominated as a vice presidential candidate
Roslin responds by pushing Wallace Gray, her policy-maker into standing as an alternative candidate
Manipulating the media, Zarek makes headway in his desire to secure the position as Vice President, with Roslin hampered by what may be the makings of an attempt on her life – possibly orchestrated by Zarek
Surprisingly, it is Gaius Baltar who comes to her aid, giving an eloquent speech through the media that reminds the people of Roslin’s qualities – and Zarek’s background. As a result, Roslin has Gray relinquish his position as her nominee in favour of Baltar
Baltar wins the nomination – through Roslin’s final intervention in an official capacity – but Zarek makes it clear matters are far from over: there is still the presidential elections due in 6 months.

On Caprica:

Helo and Valerii have reached Delphi
Helo considers the humano-Cylons to be human "replicants", created by the Cylons using human DNA.
Valerii uses this idea as a means of testing his possible feelings towards her, should she reveal her true identity
Later, as they try to enter the Cylon base at Delphi, Helo sees another Valerii, and realises the truth – which sets him on the run from the base – and Valerii herself

--Colonial Archivist 10:40, 26 Jan 2005 (EST)

Questions

Just how much freedom of movement within the fleet have Zarek’s people gained since the events of Water?
Will Zarek be able to use this apparent freedom to rally support for the forthcoming elections?
Was Zarek really behind the suspected attempt on Roslin’s life?
- If she had been assassinated before he secured the position of Vice President, he would have a prime suspect. Similarly, had she been assassinated after secured the vice presidency, he would still have been a prime suspect
- As the Vice President, he would have every opportunity to build a track record as an effective politician, and thus stand as a highly competent alternative to Roslin in the elections
How does the Quorum of Twelve relate to the Office of the President? Does it function in a similar manner to the US Congress?

Analysis

This is the most poorly-conceived and executed episode in BSG's first season. While it does make valid points about the nature and structure of Colonial society within the fleet (or at least Tom Zarek makes them very briefly), outside of the Helo/Valerii situation on Caprica, the storyline here is ultimately transparent and weak.

Specifically:

There has been no real sight nor sound of the Cloud Nine (admittedly a wonderfully-ironic name) in the fleet until now - and this is being passed off as being because she has been "under repair".
"Wallace Gray" is allegedly the power behind Roslin's throne, setting her agenda and policies, overseeing the distribution of food and medical supplies - essentially performing the role of her Chief of Staff / right-hand-man yet never once has he been previously mentioned or seen! Wallace Gray is so clearly a plot tool - and a badly-handled one at that: first he doesn't want the VP nomination, but accepts because Roslin needs him; then when asked to step down, he comes off in an embittered huff (presumably never to be seen again)
Zarek's challenge for the position of Veep is an obvious construction to lay the path for Gaius Baltar to become the Vice President
- It is surprising that, after her somewhat vicious words to him in Six Degrees of Separation, Roslin can face off with Baltar without so much as an apology for past actions - it has already been established (Secrets and Lies) that since that event she has barely spoken to him - and it hardly seems likely she'd use their time together in the Galactica's Situation Room to make her apologies / overtures of friendship (The Hand of God)
- It is equally surprising that Baltar's ego doesn't offer greater resistance to her request. True, she is to a degree pandering to his desire to be back in the limelight - but given his nature, such an open "forgive and forget" doesn't entirely sit with his nature
Baltar's ascendancy to the position of Vice President is badly telegraphed - given the synopsis, it is apparent as soon as Starbuck informs Baltar he has been selected as Caprica's representative in the Quorum
The intrigue around Valance and his gun, etc., is heavy-handed and comes across either as illogical or as padding for a storyline otherwise short on action
Security is meant to be heavy aboard the Cloud Nine - yet there is no intervention from any security personnel in what amounts to a brawl in the bar
Why, when Lee Adama has expressed concern over just about every aspect of security on the Cloud Nine, is Valance held on the ship in an obviously insecure area (air vent access) - rather than being shipped back to the Galactica, with her brig, for proper interrogation?

Indeed, it is the Valance sub-plot which is most poorly explained / illogical. Assuming Valance was working for Zarek, and was on the Cloud Nine to kill Roslin - then his presence undermines Zarek as a clever manipulator. Positioning himself for the roll of Vice President, getting the vote and then having Roslin killed - all at the same event - would inevitably point the finger at Zarek and place him at the centre of a major investigation, under the control of William Adama, which is unlikely to relent until his complicity has been proven. In short, he would be paralysing his ability to act as the President.

As Lee Adama himself states to Starbuck - once Zarek has secured the position of Vice President, he can have Roslin taken care of at any time. Indeed, given the resources now clearly at his disposal (witness the Virgon representative's comment about Zarek's people coming to his aid ahead of Roslin's), there is no reason not to suppose Zarek could arrange for Roslin to meet with an "accident" - perhaps a failure with her shuttle as she moves around the fleet - which would make his complicity very much hard to prove.

That said, there is still some excellent acting in the episode - especially where Baltar is concerned. His interview with the press and particularly his "exclusive" to Playa Palacios in the toilets and both particularly noteworthy examples of James Callis’ marvellous handling of the character but this still doesn't compensate for the rest of the time spent on Cloud Nine.

But other than this, the major story arc is a missed opportunity. Presented with a chance to explore the state of Colonial society within the fleet, and address key issues, the producers frittered the opportunity away with shallow intrigue and hollow political manoeuvring. The West Wing this was most certainly not.

The only time the episode truly comes alive is during the all-too-brief scenes on Caprica. These scenes beautifully-encapsulates all we need to know and feel:

Valerii's attempt to probe Helo about his feelings, using his "replicant" theory
Valerii is showing more symptoms of being pregnant
They reach Delphi and the chance of a ship off the planet
Helo is suddenly - and quite unexpectedly - confronted with Valerii's true nature.

This is excellent stuff, but amounts to less than 10 minutes of screen time, and it unfortunately, isn't enough to lift this episode.

Still, every show tends to misfire once or twice through the course of a season - some managing to do so a lot more frequently. We're fortunate that this is the first - and hopefully only - hiccup in what has otherwise been a highly-successful first season.

Notes

10 days have passed since the events of The Hand of God
The office of the President operates in conjunction with the Quorum of Twelve, a council of representatives of the 12 colonies
The Articles of Colonisation were signed 52 years ago
- Given the 12 colonies have been inhabited for centuries, the Articles therefore don't directly relate to the settlement of thses worlds
- However, given the timeframe (52 years) and its proximity to the first Cylon War, perhaps the original articles were the document that united the 12 colonies to fight the treat of the Cylons, and became the bases for their peaceful co-operation after the war
Issues surrounding the distribution of food and medical supplies are beginning to cause concern within the fleet
Despite being "isolated" aboard the Astral Queen (Bastille Day), Zarek has managed to use his time to build up contacts within the fleet and offer assistance to other vessels - so much so that the representative from Virgon is only too willing to throw his support behind Zarek.
Apparntly convicted felons lose their citizenship under Sagittarian penal law but have it automatically reinstated after they finish serving their sentences. This included the right to vote and to stand for election.

--Colonial Archivist 18:54, 27 Jan 2005 (EST)

Noteworthy Dialogue

Helo and Valerii have arrived in the vicinty of the Cylon base at Delphi, and the talk turns to the two women "helping" the Cylons

Helo: (Standing as Valerii crouches with her back to him, getting some food) I'm trying to make sense out of two women would sell [out] to the Cylons. Valerii: (keeping her back to him) And? Helo: I can't fathom why anybody would want to help the toasters...and they just happen to be twins? It's too weird. Valerii: You got a better explanation? Helo: Do you think the Cylons could be messing with human DNA? (Valerii reacts, mouth opening as she looks away). Cloning people or something? Valerii: (gathering herself and looking over her shoulder at Helo) Could be. Helo: (nodding and crouching) That would explain how they took us by surprise. They had these...replicated humans infiltrating the colonies, laying the groundwork for the surprise attack. Valerii: (pausing, as if considering this) You know, if they were human clones, that measn they're capable of...complex emotions - maybe even love. Maybe they were misguided in the way they were indoctrinated... Helo: (interrupting) Wait a minute! They're not human! No human could do the things they've done - killed billions of innocent people (Valerii looks away, hurt) Helo. They've got to be frakking Cylons, just like the rest of them...

Official Statements

Statistics

Guest Stars

Writing & Direction

Written by Carla Robinson
Directed by Jonas Pate

Production Notes

Series 1 (2004 / 2005)
Production Number: 1.11
Airdate Order: 11 (of 13)

First Run Air Dates & Releases

UK Airdate: 10 January 2005 (Sky One)
US Airdate: (Sci-Fi Channel)
DVD Release: N/A