Talk:Skirmish Over the Red Moon/Archive 1

I've decided that anything where a Viper gets destroyed deserves a page, so we can keep track of ships (although this won't keep track of mechanical failure). Granted, the Battle of Kobol does NOT have a single Viper get destroyed, but it was a major engagement (plus Raptors were destroyed). So the Colonials shooting down a single Raider in "Tigh Me Up, Tigh Me Down" doesn't really need a page, nor does "Final Cut" because just 2 Raiders were destroyed with no loses. I felt this was a good page to have because it resulted in a Viper destroyed, (1 also damaged but later recovered and repaired), and the capture of a Cylon Raider by the Galactica, a major military asset. ---Ricimer, 17 Sept, 2005.

Really, anything that results in deaths probably ought to get noted - which would mean we should have pages for the Gideon Massacre (Resistance) and Skirmish on the High Road (Home, Part I). --Peter Farago 12:08, 17 September 2005 (EDT)

Actually no; It's covering military engagements and only 4 people were lost there. It wasn't a real fight between both sides, and it would really be redundant because Gideon covers taht. As for Skirmish on the High Road, that information is already covered under Battle of Kobol. ---Ricimer, 17 Sept, 2005

• We shouldn't have the battle pages put into the past tense like Spencerian did; I think it makes it harder to read. --Ricimer 15:44, 14 November 2005 (EST)