Talk:Laura Roslin faction/Archive 1

Should this page include Helo and Starbuck due to the events of "Home"? The description refers primarily to the "Resistance" break-out and is rather ambiguous as to whether later events should be mentioned as well. --Redwall 20:02, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Interesting point. Helo & Starbuck are only accidental members of the faction, at best. Don't know if I'd say that Starbuck started the faction by disobeying orders and jumping to Caprica. Colonial one 23:36, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Kara is the very last person on the ship who would sit around watching Tigh make disastrous decisions while Adama was incapacitated. She already demonstrated her completely disrespect for him on far less crucial issues. Her loyalty to Adama is stronger, but he was still comatose when the Roslin Faction made their move. It defies my imagination to think she'd have stayed on Tigh's side of a Tigh/Roslin showdown. --Peter Farago 00:24, 23 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Agreed. In fact, I'd say she'd punch him a second and third time to ensure that Adama had an equally unconscious bedmate than see him in command. She'd happily be in the brig for that one, I think. She knows he's a bad commander, although she may have a begrudging respect for his military knowledge. Spencerian 00:37, 23 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Is this article worth keeping?

Is this article worth keeping? It didn't turn into as big of a thing as we thought it would. --The Merovingian ^{(C - E)} 02:29, 8 August 2006 (CDT)

Ships in the faction

Why not put a list of known ships in the page to give off the 24 ships list. I know that Astral Queen, Monarch, Adriatic, Gemenon Traveller and Gemini are on that list. --CoreyDanian 10.56 24 October 2006