Battlestar Wiki:Sock puppetry: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 01:19, 28 April 2007

This is a proposed policy for Battlestar Wiki.
This non-policy is considered by the community and its leadership is to be considered for the status quo of Battlestar Wiki, though changes to it can be discussed on the appropriate talk page.

Shortcut:
BW:SOCK

A sock puppet is a second account created by a user to give the appearance of additional support for the views or actions of the main account.

Identifying a sock puppet

Sock puppets can typically be identified by an administrator with "checkuser" privileges. Basically, this entails comparing the IP addresses of two suspected users to see if they correlate.

While not entirely conclusive, it may or may not identify sock puppets. Therefore, additional means of evidence gathering must be used. This includes:

comparing the editing patterns of the users in question, which includes:
- what articles they edit
- when they edit
- how they communicate with other users
comparing view points

Uses of a sock puppet

Sock puppets are used for two reasons:

to circumvent policy,
to give the appearance of additional "outsider" support for a certain idea or POV where outsider support is minimal or non-existant.

Sock puppets are typically used to:

Circumvent blocks or bans.
Come up in processes where voting is used as a tool to determine consensus, such as Think Tanks, Requests for adminship, Request for comment, and deletion discussions.
To present support for an argument, or to make an opposing argument weaker through the use of "straw man" argumentation.
For the purposes of trolling while maintaining an account that is viewed as "legitimate".

Accepted uses

There is only one accepted use for a "sock puppet" account on Battlestar Wiki.

Bots

Main article: Battlestar Wiki:Bots

Bots are considered a type of "sock puppet" run by a contributor on the wiki. Bots are types of programs that work on maintenance tasks on the wiki, such as listing articles that have been categorized for cleanup, merges, splits or have been identified as articles that are requested or are stubs that need the attention of contributors.

Bots are vetted through a verification and testing process prior to deployment on the wiki and can be blocked if they cause problems.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{Proposed Policy}}
+{{Proposed Policy|shortcut=BW:SOCK|23 March 2007}}
-A Sock Puppet is a second account created by a user to give the appearance of additional support for the views or actions of the main account.
+A '''sock puppet''' is a second account created by a user to give the appearance of additional support for the views or actions of the main account.
+== Identifying a sock puppet ==
+Sock puppets can typically be identified by an administrator with "checkuser" privileges. Basically, this entails comparing the IP addresses of two suspected users to see if they correlate.
+While not entirely conclusive, it may or may not identify sock puppets. Therefore, additional means of evidence gathering must be used. This includes:
+* comparing the editing patterns of the users in question, which includes:
+** what articles they edit
+** when they edit
+** how they communicate with other users
+* comparing view points
+== Uses of a sock puppet ==
+Sock puppets are used for two reasons:
+# to circumvent [[Battlestar Wiki:Policy|policy]],
+# to give the appearance of additional "outsider" support for a certain idea or POV where outsider support is minimal or non-existant.
+Sock puppets are typically used to:
+# Circumvent [[BW:BLOCK|blocks]] or [[BW:BAN|bans]].
+# Come up in processes where voting is used as a tool to determine consensus, such as [[BW:TANK|Think Tank]]s, [[BW:RFA|Requests for adminship]], [[BW:RFC|Request for comment]], and [[Battlestar Wiki:Candidates for deletion|deletion discussions]].
+# To present support for an argument, or to make an opposing argument weaker through the use of "[[w:straw man|straw man]]" argumentation.
+# For the purposes of [[w:internet troll|trolling]] while maintaining an account that is viewed as "legitimate".
+== Accepted uses ==
+There is only one accepted use for a "sock puppet" account on ''Battlestar Wiki''.
+=== Bots ===
+{{mainarticle|Battlestar Wiki:Bots}}
+Bots are considered a type of "sock puppet" run by a contributor on the wiki. Bots are types of programs that work on [[Battlestar Wiki:Tasks|maintenance tasks]] on the wiki, such as listing articles that have been categorized for cleanup, merges, splits or have been identified as articles that are requested or are stubs that need the attention of contributors.
+Bots are vetted through a verification and testing process prior to deployment on the wiki and can be blocked if they cause problems.