Editing Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck 4

{{separate continuity|universe=TOS|cont=Dynamite Comics}}

{{Comic Data
| image = Starbuck04CovChen.jpg
| title=Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck #4
| series=Dynamite
| issueno=4
| episode=
| writer= [[Tony Lee]]
| penciller= 
| inker= [[Eman Casallos]]
| colorist= [[Davi Correia]] (pages); [[Adriano Lucas]] (cover)
| letterer= [[Joshua Cozine]]
| editor=
| cover= [[Sean Chen]]
| published=Feburary 2014
| collects=
| collected=[[Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck (Trade Paperback)|Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck]]
| reprints=
| reprinted=
| isbn= 725130209306
| prev=[[Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck 3]]
| next=
}}

:''FINAL ISSUE!!! The origin of Lt. {{alt|Starbuck|TOS}} concludes, told by #1 New York Times best-selling author [[Tony Lee]]! On an ice world in the middle of [[Cylon (TOS alternate)|Cylon]] space, Starbuck and {{alt|Apollo|TOS}} race to free {{alt|Athena|TOS}} before {{TOS|Osiris|Osiris}} can use her in his vendetta against {{alt|Adama|TOS}} - but are they too late to save [[Twelve Colonies of Man|the colonies]] from Cylon invasion?''<ref>{{cite_web|url=https://www.dynamite.com/htmlfiles/viewProduct.html?PRO=C72513020930600411|title=
BATTLESTAR GALACTICA: STARBUCK #4 (OF 4)|date=|accessdate=28 May 2019|last=|first=|format=|language=}}</ref>

== Plot ==

: ''As with the [[Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck 2|previous two installments]], this issue is set entirely two [[yahren]]s before the [[Battle of Cimtar|attack at Cimtar]].''

* On the ice moon {{TOS|Thrace|Thrace}}, {{alt|Athena|TOS}} is imprisoned in the "abandoned" mining center's holding cell. {{TOS|Diana|Diana}} informs her that Athena will die anyway, regardless of whether or not {{alt|Adama|TOS}} resigns and destroys [[McKintosh]]'s [[Umbra]] data.
* Diana has begun a melt-down of the fusion reactor, which will not only kill Athena but wipe out Osiris's and Diana's proof of a connection with the [[Cylon (TOS alternate)|Cylon]].
* Diana further taunts Athena, reminiscing of her memories of Athena's time in the [[Academy]], and how Athena should have focused her efforts on learning Vipers and battle tactics instead of computers and com-systems.
* When Diana leaves, Athena uses her scorned electronics knowledge to identify the [[Grayson]] model door pad, and uses a thread of bare [[chronium]] from her uniform's braiding to short out the control pad. 
* {{alt|Apollo|TOS}} and {{alt|Starbuck|TOS}} land on Thrace, observing Cylon [[Centurion (TOS alternate)|Centurion]] loading tylium into their [[Raider (TOS alternate)|Raider]]. 
* Starbuck apologies to Apollo for his pursuit of the information on McKintosh's pendant. Apollo points out that Osiris would still be on the {{TOS|Quorum of Twelve|Quorum of Twelve}} and the Cylons would be one step closer to wiping them out, to which Starbuck notes that Osiris is ''still'' on the Quorum and it is the Warriors who are on the run. 
* Apollo notes that this will soon change, and with the Cylons prepping to depart, this distraction affords them the opportunity to enter the "abandoned" mine. Instead of planning a careful way in, Apollo decides to go in [[laser pistol|laser]] blazing, taking a leaf from Starbuck's book.
* Meanwhile, an intruder alarm blazes as Athena makes good her escape. Nearby, Athena overhears Diana screaming to a Centurion saying that the intruders are of no concern as the reactor will explode within [[micron]]s. 
* When the Centurion departs, Diana calls out Athena from hiding. Tired of Diana's taunting, Athena attacks Diana.
* Apollo and Starbuck enter the security room. Starbuck discovers that the reactor is rigged to blow, and also finds Athena in a fight with Diana on the monitors.
* Apollo intercedes before Athena bludgeons Diana to death. Starbuck arrives and is about to finish Diana off as revenge for [[Kandi Trieste]]'s death, but Diana escapes during a rumbling of the overloading reactor.
* They flee the abandoned mine, but a group of Centurions are between them and their Vipers. However, a group of Vipers clears this obstruction, facilitating their escape.
* Meanwhile, Diana attempts to abort the meltdown, which is too far along at that point. 
* [[Lucifer (alternate)|Lucifer]] opens visual communication with Diana, commenting on her predicament. She tells Lucifer that the Cylons need to stop the Viper pilots before they return to ''Galactica'' before they reveal Osiris, but Lucifer replies that they already have secured an alternate traitor for their cause.
* Lucifer also tells her that any rescue attempt would not arrive in time, suggesting that she make peace with her [[Lords of Kobol (TOS)|"Human Gods"]].
* On {{alt|Caprica|TOS}}, Osiris is pulled from a Quorum meeting due to an urgent message from his daughter. Angrily, he leaves and enters a nearby communication room, only to receive one final, tear-filled message from Diana: "Father... I ''love'' you..."
* The Thrace mining facility explodes, with the Vipers narrowly escaping the blast. A phalanx of Cylon Raiders arrives to intercept them, with Zac engaging and destroying one cockily. However, Zac is pursued by another Raider and requests assistance, this Raider is dispatched by his father&mdash;who jokingly notes that Zac used to whine about spiders<ref name="errorterm">See [[#Errata|Errata]] for the term that Adama should have used instead.</ref> in much the same way. 
* Zac notes the arrival of a Cylon [[basestar (TOS alternate)|basestar]] on his [[scanner]]. After some joking at Starbuck's expense, Apollo insists to Adama that they should leave. Adama replies that they have one last card to play for a [[full pyramid]].
* Tigh communicates to Adama in the newly arrived ''Galactica'', which also boasts additional Viper wings. Adama instructs Tigh to "teach these [[toaster]]s<ref name="errorterm"/> a lesson."
* A Centurion reports ''Galactica''{{'|s}} arrival to Lucifer. Lucifer orders retreat, allowing the [[Warrior]]s to "return home to do our bidding." 
* Zac gleefully notes the retreat, but Adama morosely notes that the Cylons had them out-gunned and their retreat was something they wanted. 
* Starbuck has now re-set his sights on Osiris, and they return to ''Galactica'' so that they may present their evidence to the Quorum in force.
* Councilor {{TOS|Romo|Romo}} informs President [[Adar (TOS alternate)|Adar]] that Adama has arrived. As Osiris attempts to leave, Starbuck blocks the door way with [[Baltar (TOS alternate)|Baltar]] in tow. Adar is incensed that Starbuck has his [[laser pistol]] drawn in the chamber. Osiris calls for guards, but Starbuck plays back McKintosh's testimony. 
* Osiris pulls out his own laser pistol, and shoots at Starbuck while taking Adar hostage. Osiris demands a shuttle, but is thwarted when Starbuck shoots Osiris dead. 
* Adar reflects on seeming to have a "terrible judge of character," and asks for Adama to resume his post on the Quorum. Adama accepts this offer. 
* Starbuck notes the vacancy in the Quorum to Baltar, to which Baltar agrees gratefully.
* On ''Galactica'', President Adar presides from a podium, officially recognizing the efforts of Baltar, Adama, Starbuck, and Apollo in uncovering Osiris's treachery and removal from the Quorum. Adama is officially reinstated, while Baltar is given Osiris's seat on the Quorum. Additionally, Adar announces the promotion of Apollo and Starbuck to Captain and Lieutenant respectfully. 
* After the ceremony, Adama commends Starbuck for his actions, claiming that not only [[Wyler]] would be proud, but also Starbuck's family. Starbuck replies that his family is on ''Galactica''.
* Athena follows up and "thanks" Starbuck with a kiss, which confuses Starbuck as Apollo chides him for being "struck down by his one weakness&mdash;''women''!"
* Later, at the [[Memorial to the Colonial Warrior]], Starbuck reflects to Apollo that their names were almost added to it. As they discuss their next steps, Jolly, Zac and Boomer arrive and Starbuck asks if they had ever sampled the "joys of the {{TOS|Rising Star|Rising Star}}."
* Meanwhile, Baltar is in communication with the [[Imperious Leader (alternate)|Imperious Leader]], noting that he is now in the perfect position to bring the Cylons the victory they seek, for he is seen as a hero. He tells the Imperious Leader that he will need two [[yahren]]s to con the Colonials into believing that the Cylons want nothing more than peace. 
* Imperious Leader reminds Baltar that Osiris was sacrificed to make way for Baltar's new position of power, noting that while Baltar can manipulate and acquire power as he will, Baltar ultimately serves the Cylons.

== Notes ==

=== Nods ===

* The ice moon of {{TOS|Thrace|Thrace}} is a nod to [[Kara Thrace|Kara "Starbuck" Thrace]] from the [[Re-imagined Series]].
* President [[Adar (TOS alternate)|Adar]]'s statement regarding his being "a terrible judge of character" regarding {{TOS|Osiris|Osiris}} is a nod to Adar's misplaced trust in {{TOS|Baltar}}, as well as his final words in "[[Saga of a Star World]]" before ''{{TOS|Atlantia|Atlantia}}'' is destroyed at {{TOS|Cimtar|Cimtar}}.
* ''{{TOS|Rising Star|Rising Star}}'' is mentioned at the end of this story. It would later be the last surviving entertainment ship in the [[The Fleet (TOS)|rag-tag, fugitive fleet]].

=== Errata ===

* As with other entries in the [[Dynamite Entertainment]] comics, a mix of [[Re-Imagined Series]] and [[Original Series]] [[terminology|terminologies]] occurs:
** The backgrounds of the Viper bay on battlestar ''[[Galactica (TOS alternate)|Galactica]]'' are those of the [[hangar deck]] from the [[TRS|Re-imagined Series]].
** The Warrior uniforms feature shoulder patches on both shoulders, but it should only appear on the right shoulder on {{TOS|Uniforms|Warrior uniforms}}.
** The Vipers depicted are visually more in line with the Re-imagined Series [[Mark II Viper]] than the {{TOS|Viper|Original Series counterpart}}.
** Civilians wear contemporary clothing (modern suits with ties, vests, tank tops, red dresses, t-shirts) as opposed to the distinct Egyptian-esque clothing designed by [[Jean-Pierre Dorleac]].
** In the background during [[Adar (TOS alternate)|Adar]]'s ceremony commemorating the actions of Apollo, Starbuck, Adama and Baltar, a large wall plaque for the "Office of the President" features the [[Colonial seal]] from the Re-imagined Series. The plaque is directly reminiscent of the one first featured in President [[Richard Adar]]'s office in "[[Epiphanies]]."
* {{TOS|List of terms|Terminology}} issues:
** After {{alt|Adama|TOS}} destroys a [[Raider (TOS alternate)|Raider]] pursuing [[Zac (TOS alternate)|Zac]], he tells Zac to stop whining, and noted that "he used to be the same way about spiders." The term for "spider" established in "[[Lost Planet of the Gods, Part I]]" is "[[crawlon]]."
** The word "toaster" is used to describe Cylons, which is a term used in the [[Re-imagined Series]]. The [[Original Series]] coined the term "[[tinhead]]" in "[[The Living Legend, Part I]]."
* The issue continues in its contradiction regarding [[Kandi Trieste]]'s employment. In ''[[Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck 2]]'', she is employed in the [[Astral Utopia]] on {{TOS|Caprica|Caprica}}. However, it is implied that she worked on the ''[[Erin Dream]]''.
* In ''Starbuck #2'', Apollo points out Adama's rank as "Colonel," but later in this issue Adar refers to him as "Commander." Somewhere along the way he receives a promotion or, more likely, this is an error that was not caught during editing as ''[[Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck 1|Starbuck #1]]'' made use of rank changes to denote the passage of time.

== Analysis ==

* The treasonous motives of both {{TOS|Osiris|Osiris}} and {{TOS|Diana|Diana}} are not in any way fleshed out, in keeping with the tradition of established story telling in the series proper. There is a vague insinuation of power acquisition, and perhaps it could be argued that the Cylons also agreed to spare Osiris' colony of [[Aeries]] (assuming that the Cylons gave them the same deal as the one they gave {{TOS|Baltar}}), but this is paper-thin as motivation.
* The ending scene of the comic implies that Baltar was recruited by the Cylons before Starbuck resurrected the threat of [[McKintosh]]'s [[Umbra]] recording.

== Questions ==

* Why would anyone betray their homeworlds to the {{TOS|Cylon|Cylon}}s?
* When was Baltar recruited by the Cylons? 
* What is Baltar's plan to bring about the downfall of the Colonies in two [[yarhen]]s? ([[Battle of Cimtar|Answer]])

== Noteworthy Dialogue ==

* ''{{alt|Apollo|TOS}} engages the [[Cylon (TOS alternate)|Cylon]]s outside of the {{TOS|tylium|tylium}} mine:''
*: '''Starbuck:''' What the [[frack]] are you ''doing''?
*: '''Apollo:''' Taking a leaf out of your book! ''Leaping in with both feet!''
*: '''Starbuck:''' That's with girls! Apollo&mdash;''That's with girls! Not Cylons!''

== Gallery ==
<gallery mode="slideshow">
Starbuck04CovChen.jpg|Colorized cover.
Starbuck041.jpg|Page 1
Starbuck042.jpg|Page 2
Starbuck043.jpg|Page 3
Starbuck044.jpg|Page 4
Starbuck045.jpg|Page 5
</gallery>

== External links ==

* [http://www.dynamiteentertainment.com/htmlfiles/viewProduct.html?PRO=C72513020930600411 ''Battlestar Galactica: Starbuck #4''] at Dynamite Entertainment

==References==
{{reflist}}

{{tabnav|comicslist|comics=starbuck}}

[[Category:A to Z]]
[[Category:Comics]]
[[Category:Comics (TOS)]]
[[Category:Dynamite Comics]]
[[Category:Dynamite Comics (TOS)]]
{{indicator|TOS}}[[Category:TOS]]