Battlestar Wiki:Guide to improving articles: Difference between revisions

From Battlestar Wiki, the free, open content Battlestar Galactica encyclopedia and episode guide
(wow this needs a reall good cleanup and rewrite)
(cleanup done)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{cleanup}}
Battlestar Wiki's articles are like living things: they are born into [[Battlestar Wiki:Perfect stub article|stubhood]] and (ideally) grow up into [[Battlestar Wiki:Featured articles|well-written, comprehensive]] articles. Unlike other living things, articles have an infinite life expectancy (excepting [[Battlestar Wiki:What Battlestar Wiki is not|inappropriate]] articles that get [[Battlestar Wiki:Candidates for deletion|deleted]]).


Wikipedia's articles are like living things: they are born into [[Battlestar Wiki:Perfect stub article|stubhood]] and (ideally) grow up into [[Battlestar Wiki:The perfect article|well-written, comprehensive]] articles. Unlike other living things, articles have an infinite life expectancy (excepting [[Battlestar Wiki:What Batlestar Wiki is not|inappropriate]] articles that get [[Battlstar Wiki:Deletion policy|deleted]]).
This page details the different stages in an article's life, and lists the various ways '''you can help articles grow''' into the next stage. Note that skipping stages is allowed — in fact, it's a very good thing if you can accomplish this! Also, there is no hard line in-between stages. These are rough categories to help you get an idea of how articles typically grow on Battlestar Wiki.


This page details the different stages in an article's life, and lists the various ways '''you can help articles grow''' into the next stage. Note that skipping stages is allowed — in fact, it's a very good thing if you can accomplish this! Also, there is no hard line in-between stages. These are rough categories to help you get an idea of how articles typically grow on Wikipedia.
Please note that this life cycle does not concern itself with [[Battlestar Wiki:Candidates for deletion|votes for deletion]], [[:Category:Articles suggested to be merged|merging]], [[:Category:Articles suggested to be split|splitting]], [[Battlestar Wiki:Template List|templates]], [[Battlestar Wiki:Image use policy|images]], [[Battlestar Wiki:Categories|categories]], or any of the other issues and organizational techniques that will crop up from time to time.


Please note that this life cycle does not concern itself with [[Battlestar Wiki:Votes for deletion|votes for deletion]], [[Wikipedia:Duplicate articles|merging]], [[:Category:Articles to be split|splitting]], [[Wikipedia:Template messages|templates]], [[Battlestar Wiki:Images|images]], [[Battlestar Wiki:Category|categories]], or any of the other issues and organizational techniques that will crop up from time to time. See: [[Battlestar Wiki:Utilities]].
==[[Battlestar Wiki:Tutorial (Editing)|Uncreated article]]==
 
Every article starts with an idea in the mind of a contributor. You should create articles about whatever you are interested in, so long as they [[Battlestar Wiki:What Battlestar Wiki is not|belong in Battlestar Wiki]]. If you see a [[w:Red link|red link]] that strikes your fancy, create an article! For more suggestions on how to think of subjects to contribute on, see [[Battlestar Wiki:Welcome|how]].
 
==[[Wikipedia:Help:Starting a new page|Uncreated article]]==
Every article starts with an idea in the mind of a contributor. You should create articles about whatever you are interested in, so long as they [[Battlestar Wiki:What Battlestar Wiki is not|belong in Wikipedia]]. If you see a [[MediaWiki:Red link|red link]] that strikes your fancy, create an article! For more suggestions on how to think of subjects to contribute on, see [[Battlestar Wiki:Contributing to Battlestar Wiki]].


Before you begin, it's helpful to read the [[Wikipedia:Your first article|guidelines]] and [[Battlestar Wiki:Tutorial|tutorials]] on creating new articles to get an idea of what you should consider (article scope, lead, organization, internal and external links, references, NPOV, etc.)
Before you begin, it's helpful to read the [[Wikipedia:Your first article|guidelines]] and [[Battlestar Wiki:Tutorial|tutorials]] on creating new articles to get an idea of what you should consider (article scope, lead, organization, internal and external links, references, NPOV, etc.)
Line 17: Line 14:
*[[Special:Lonelypages|Orphaned Pages]] (or pages that really need to be linked to another entry)
*[[Special:Lonelypages|Orphaned Pages]] (or pages that really need to be linked to another entry)


==[[Wikipedia:Perfect stub article|Stub]]==
==[[Battlestar Wiki:Find or fix a stub|Stub]]==
If you do not have the time to write a full article, consider writing a "stub" after reading how to create the [[Wikipedia:perfect stub article|perfect stub article]].
If you do not have the time to write a full article, consider writing a "stub" after reading how to create the [[Battlestar Wiki:perfect stub article|perfect stub article]].
Stubs are very short articles, generally of one paragraph or less. These are the "[[Wikipedia:The Ugly Duckling|ugly ducklings]]" of Wikipedia. With effort, they can grow into swans, of course.
Stubs are very short articles, generally of one paragraph or less. These are the "[[Wikipedia:The Ugly Duckling|ugly ducklings]]" of Battlestar Wiki. With effort, they can grow into swans, of course.


Good ways to find and grow stubs:
Good ways to find and grow stubs:
Line 34: Line 31:


===Disputed article===
===Disputed article===
Occasionally a developing article (or even a good or great article) will get sick: two or more editors disagree with each other and have trouble reaching a compromise. These articles need extra "tender loving care" from [[Wikipedia:Mediation|mediators]] who are willing to help all parties come to a consensus.
Occasionally a developing article (or even a good or great article) will get sick: two or more editors disagree with each other and have trouble reaching a compromise. These articles need extra "tender loving care" from mediators who are willing to help all parties come to a consensus.


If you choose to help these articles out as a mediator, please keep [[Wikipedia:Wikiquette|Wikiquette]] and [[Wikipedia:Civility|civility]] in mind at all times. ''[[Wikipedia:Staying cool when the editing gets hot|Stay cool when the editing gets hot]]''.
If you choose to help these articles out as a mediator, please keep [[Battlestar Wiki:Etiquette|etiquette]] and [[Battlestar Wiki:Civility|civility]] in mind at all times. ''[[Wikipedia:Staying cool when the editing gets hot|Stay cool when the editing gets hot]]''.


If you find yourself involved as one of the editors, '''don't panic'''. Re-read the three pages linked in the previous paragraph, and follow their advice. If a bitter revert war is in progress, submit a request for [[Wikipedia:Requests for page protection|page protection]] to any members of the Battlestar Wiki [[Special:Listadmins|administration]]. Ask some neutral [[:Category:Wikipedians|Wikipedians]] to come mediate the dispute.
If you find yourself involved as one of the editors, '''don't panic'''. Re-read the three pages linked in the previous paragraph, and follow their advice. If a bitter revert war is in progress, submit a request for [[Wikipedia:Requests for page protection|page protection]] to any members of the Battlestar Wiki [[Special:Listadmins|administration]]. Ask some neutral [[:Category:Wikipedians|Wikipedians]] to come mediate the dispute.
Line 47: Line 44:
*[[Wikipedia:Accuracy dispute]]
*[[Wikipedia:Accuracy dispute]]
*[[Wikipedia:Disputed statement]]
*[[Wikipedia:Disputed statement]]
*[[Wikipedia:Requests for page protection]]


==Good article==
==[[Battlestar Wiki:Quality Articles|Good article]]==
A good article has one or more contributors dedicated to improving the article's quality. The article at least tries to be comprehensive. Many [[:Category:Wikipedians|Wikipedians]] "sponsor" or "adopt" a small number of articles, which they add to their [[Wikipedia:Watchlist help|watchlists]] and update whenever they can. Please note that once an article has been "adopted" by one Wikipedian, there's no reason that you shouldn't "adopt" it too, if it strikes your fancy. With two editors collaborating on the same article, it will often improve three times as fast.
A good article has one or more contributors dedicated to improving the article's quality. The article at least tries to be comprehensive. Many [[:Category:Wikipedians|Wikipedians]] "sponsor" or "adopt" a small number of articles, which they add to their [[Wikipedia:Watchlist help|watchlists]] and update whenever they can. Please note that once an article has been "adopted" by one Wikipedian, there's no reason that you shouldn't "adopt" it too, if it strikes your fancy. With two editors collaborating on the same article, it will often improve three times as fast.


==[[Wikipedia:How to write a great article|Great article]]==
==[[Wikipedia:How to write a great article|Great article]]==
After thorough peer review, with lots of people working together to smooth out the rough edges, a good article can become [[Wikipedia:How to write a great article|great]]. You'll know a great article when you see it. It's steadily approaching [[Wikipedia:The perfect article|perfection]]. Polish it up as best you can, maybe give it another round in [[Wikipedia:Peer review|peer review]].
After thorough peer review, with lots of people working together to smooth out the rough edges, a good article can become [[Wikipedia:How to write a great article|great]]. You'll know a great article when you see it. It's steadily approaching [[Battlestar Wiki:Featured articles|perfection]]. Polish it up as best you can, maybe give it another round in [[Battlestar Wiki:Quality Articles|peer review]].


How to get great articles up to featured-quality:
How to get great articles up to featured-quality:
*[[Wikipedia:Peer review]]
*[[Battlestar Wiki:Quality Articles]]


==Beyond...==
==Beyond...==
Featured articles are well-polished, but there are almost always small improvements that can be made. Don't ever be afraid to correct mistakes when you see them; no article is [[Wikipedia:The perfect article|perfect]], though perfection will always remain our goal.
Featured articles are well-polished, but there are almost always small improvements that can be made. Don't ever be afraid to correct mistakes when you see them; no article is [[Battlestar Wiki:Featured articles|perfect]], though perfection will always remain our goal.


Without a doubt, though, our featured articles are excellent, so why not show them off? There are a number of ways you can showcase our best work to people who might not know about Battlestar Wiki. This is an excellent way to [[Wikipedia:Building Wikipedia membership|recruit new Wikipedians]] and gain [[donations]], both of which help Battlestar Wikiimmensely.
Without a doubt, though, our featured articles are excellent, so why not show them off? There are a number of ways you can showcase our best work to people who might not know about Battlestar Wiki. This is an excellent way to [[Wikipedia:Building Wikipedia membership|recruit new Wikipedians]] and gain [[Battlestar Wiki:Site support|donations]], both of which help Battlestar Wiki immensely.

Revision as of 23:01, 20 March 2007

Battlestar Wiki's articles are like living things: they are born into stubhood and (ideally) grow up into well-written, comprehensive articles. Unlike other living things, articles have an infinite life expectancy (excepting inappropriate articles that get deleted).

This page details the different stages in an article's life, and lists the various ways you can help articles grow into the next stage. Note that skipping stages is allowed — in fact, it's a very good thing if you can accomplish this! Also, there is no hard line in-between stages. These are rough categories to help you get an idea of how articles typically grow on Battlestar Wiki.

Please note that this life cycle does not concern itself with votes for deletion, merging, splitting, templates, images, categories, or any of the other issues and organizational techniques that will crop up from time to time.

Uncreated article

Every article starts with an idea in the mind of a contributor. You should create articles about whatever you are interested in, so long as they belong in Battlestar Wiki. If you see a red link that strikes your fancy, create an article! For more suggestions on how to think of subjects to contribute on, see how.

Before you begin, it's helpful to read the guidelines and tutorials on creating new articles to get an idea of what you should consider (article scope, lead, organization, internal and external links, references, NPOV, etc.)

Good ways to find articles to create:

Stub

If you do not have the time to write a full article, consider writing a "stub" after reading how to create the perfect stub article. Stubs are very short articles, generally of one paragraph or less. These are the "ugly ducklings" of Battlestar Wiki. With effort, they can grow into swans, of course.

Good ways to find and grow stubs:

Developing article

Once a stub has some real content, it's a real article. The vast majority of articles fall into this category. They may have mistakes, but you are encouraged to copyedit and correct them.

Good ways to find and improve developing articles:

Disputed article

Occasionally a developing article (or even a good or great article) will get sick: two or more editors disagree with each other and have trouble reaching a compromise. These articles need extra "tender loving care" from mediators who are willing to help all parties come to a consensus.

If you choose to help these articles out as a mediator, please keep etiquette and civility in mind at all times. Stay cool when the editing gets hot.

If you find yourself involved as one of the editors, don't panic. Re-read the three pages linked in the previous paragraph, and follow their advice. If a bitter revert war is in progress, submit a request for page protection to any members of the Battlestar Wiki administration. Ask some neutral Wikipedians to come mediate the dispute.

Good ways to find and heal disputed articles:

Good article

A good article has one or more contributors dedicated to improving the article's quality. The article at least tries to be comprehensive. Many Wikipedians "sponsor" or "adopt" a small number of articles, which they add to their watchlists and update whenever they can. Please note that once an article has been "adopted" by one Wikipedian, there's no reason that you shouldn't "adopt" it too, if it strikes your fancy. With two editors collaborating on the same article, it will often improve three times as fast.

Great article

After thorough peer review, with lots of people working together to smooth out the rough edges, a good article can become great. You'll know a great article when you see it. It's steadily approaching perfection. Polish it up as best you can, maybe give it another round in peer review.

How to get great articles up to featured-quality:

Beyond...

Featured articles are well-polished, but there are almost always small improvements that can be made. Don't ever be afraid to correct mistakes when you see them; no article is perfect, though perfection will always remain our goal.

Without a doubt, though, our featured articles are excellent, so why not show them off? There are a number of ways you can showcase our best work to people who might not know about Battlestar Wiki. This is an excellent way to recruit new Wikipedians and gain donations, both of which help Battlestar Wiki immensely.