Battlestar Wiki:Think Tank/Deletion discussions

This article is actively undergoing a major edit for the next hour. As a courtesy, please do not edit this article while this message is displayed. The person who added this notice is Catrope.

This is a proposed policy for Battlestar Wiki. This non-policy is considered by the community and its leadership is to be considered for the status quo of Battlestar Wiki, though changes to it can be discussed on the appropriate talk page.

Overview

When an administrator deletes an article, its content can no longer be examined by non-administrators. Since these users must also have the opportunity to review the deletion process and object if they feel the deletion was unwarranted. For this reason, administrators must preserve the talk page, where the discussion leading up to the page's deletion has taken place. These pages are called 'deletion discussion pages'. This policy formalizes the procedures for preserving and tagging these talk pages, and for objecting against deletions that have already happened.

Procedures

Deleting an article

Before deleting an article, first ensure the deletion has been discussed and voted upon. After deleting the article itself, do not delete the talk page, but tag it with the deleted discussion template, like this:

{{deletion discussion}}

When tagging a talk page whose parent article lived outside of the main namespace, please provide the parent's full name as a parameter. For example, when tagging Category talk:RDM, use:

{{deletion discussion|Category:RDM}}

Note that the talk page should not be locked, as all users must be able to object to the deletion.

Temporary undeletion

A user who wishes to review a deleted article in order to gain better understanding of its deletion discussion or to make the current discussion easier can request temporary undeletion by recreating the page and tagging it with the {{undelete}} template. The article in question must be undeleted by the administrator in question as soon as possible, tagged with the {{tempundelete}} template, locked from editing, and be kept around for seven days. If a vote is started before the end of the seven-day period, the article must be kept until the voting is over. After that, one of the following things can happen:

• The user who requests undeletion doesn't pursue the issue, and the article is re-deleted silently.
• A majority of the voters wants the article to be deleted, and the article is re-deleted.
• A majority of the voters wants to keep the article. The article is unlocked and stripped of its {{tempundelete}} tag.
• A user (or users) thinks they can improve (or 'reboot') the article to meet Battlestar Wiki's quality standards. See the section below for the exact procedure.

Relevant templates and categories

• Template:Deletion discussion for tagging a deletion discussion page.
• Template:Undelete for requesting undeletion
• Template:Tempundelete for tagging temporarily undeleted pages.
• Template:Improvedundelete for tagging improvements in progress or under voting.

• Category:Deletion discussions contains all deletion discussion pages.
• Category:Requests for undeletion contains all pages pending temporary undeletion.
• Category:Temporarily undeleted pages contains all pages that have been undeleted temporarily.
• Category:Improvements to temporarily undeleted pages contains all improvements that are currently in progress or under voting.