Talk:Raptor 718/Archive 1

Possibly Recovered?

I'm going to go out on a limb here and provocate that we haven't seen the last of this Raptor, nor its fate-sibling (Raptor 314). While the battle was chaotic and the Pegasus in dire straits, there isn't proof against a recovering "tug" of the two Raptors back into Pegasus while the rest of the fight was underway. Judging by the scene prior to the arrival of Cylon basestars, the distance from Pegasus to the two adrift Raptors wasn't that great, and it cannot be completely assumed that the two Raptors were abandoned. NATO military forces have this habit of going back into, or enduring, dire battle situations to recovered deceased members quite often. While we can speculate that the Raptor was lost, on account of the tremendous attack by the Cylons, we can equally speculate that it was actually recovered in spite of such an attack. -- Hawke 02:37, 21 February 2006 (EST)

With three basestars bearing down on them, nukes hitting the ship, racing to get out, I find it incredibly improbable. We should presume that they were destroyed.--The Merovingian 02:59, 21 February 2006 (EST)

One unlucky Raptor number

Given what has happened to both Raptor 718s, this doesn't appear to be a very lucky number for them. And "Shark" seems to be a bad callsign for Raptor crew. (Lyla "Shark" Ellway, ECO on the Pegasus 718 & J. "Shark" Finnegan, pilot of the Galactica 718) I'm going out on a bit of a limb, but it's possible the writers did this on purpose. ZeldaTheSwordsman 17:52, 17 March 2009 (UTC)