User talk:Feldspar: Difference between revisions

Discussion page of User:Feldspar
No edit summary
 
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Random question for the other contributors, occasionally, I will read something here that I think is very speculative considering what we've seen.  An example is in [[Resistance]] where one of the comments is that [[Hot Dog]] is now leading combat air patrols.  This is a nitpicky example but I don't recall seeing anywhere that he was merely that he was a pilot flying the patrol and as the one nearest Roslin's shuttle was the craft ordered to intercept.  I suppose I could go in and remove these entries but this seems like bad form on my part.  What are others thoughts on this?  Is there a location that a debate on a given interpretation can be posted for input from others?
Random question for the other contributors, occasionally, I will read something here that I think is very speculative considering what we've seen.  An example is in [[Resistance]] where one of the comments is that [[Hot Dog]] is now leading combat air patrols.  This is a nitpicky example but I don't recall seeing anywhere that he was merely that he was a pilot flying the patrol and as the one nearest Roslin's shuttle was the craft ordered to intercept.  I suppose I could go in and remove these entries but this seems like bad form on my part.  What are others thoughts on this?  Is there a location that a debate on a given interpretation can be posted for input from others?
:That was my addition. I surmised it because he was taking orders directly from Tigh. If someone else in that wing had been of a higher rank, that's the one Tigh would have been speaking to. I suppose you could be right - we've only seen a CAP once (in [[33]]), so even though it was in tight formation in that episode, that needn't be the rule. --[[User:Peter Farago|Peter Farago]] 15:38, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Revision as of 19:38, 22 August 2005

Random question for the other contributors, occasionally, I will read something here that I think is very speculative considering what we've seen. An example is in Resistance where one of the comments is that Hot Dog is now leading combat air patrols. This is a nitpicky example but I don't recall seeing anywhere that he was merely that he was a pilot flying the patrol and as the one nearest Roslin's shuttle was the craft ordered to intercept. I suppose I could go in and remove these entries but this seems like bad form on my part. What are others thoughts on this? Is there a location that a debate on a given interpretation can be posted for input from others?

That was my addition. I surmised it because he was taking orders directly from Tigh. If someone else in that wing had been of a higher rank, that's the one Tigh would have been speaking to. I suppose you could be right - we've only seen a CAP once (in 33), so even though it was in tight formation in that episode, that needn't be the rule. --Peter Farago 15:38, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)