Editing User talk:Pokrface
Discussion page of User:Pokrface
More actions
The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
Welcome to the wiki, Pokrface! I was looking over your first contribution in the latest episode article. While, as you may know, we support [[BW:CJ|plausible speculation]] here, there is so very very little that we know of the medical side of the show that such a drug could have been stored on ''Galactica'' as well, even at its decommissioning, which doesn't support the final offloading of supplies, only its battle-ready ships and ordnance as shown in the miniseries. (Note that ''Galactica'' is a massive ship). Could you elaborate on your source or reasoning based on source? If there is no source, would you remove the item? I would normally do this, but I don't like blowing away a first-post today since it is logical, although it's not factual to the show. :) --[[User:Spencerian|Spencerian]] 22:17, 30 January 2007 (CST) | Welcome to the wiki, Pokrface! I was looking over your first contribution in the latest episode article. While, as you may know, we support [[BW:CJ|plausible speculation]] here, there is so very very little that we know of the medical side of the show that such a drug could have been stored on ''Galactica'' as well, even at its decommissioning, which doesn't support the final offloading of supplies, only its battle-ready ships and ordnance as shown in the miniseries. (Note that ''Galactica'' is a massive ship). Could you elaborate on your source or reasoning based on source? If there is no source, would you remove the item? I would normally do this, but I don't like blowing away a first-post today since it is logical, although it's not factual to the show. :) --[[User:Spencerian|Spencerian]] 22:17, 30 January 2007 (CST) | ||
Thanks for the welcome. The supposition that the interrogation drug would be off-loaded during the decommissioning is tied into the nature of the product. If it's a weapon--materiel, like chemical weapons--it would have been taken off along with the rest of the materiel. If it's classified as medical supplies, likely its fate would be the same as the other medical supplies, which apparently stay during decommissioning. Either way, though, you're right that it's pure speculation. [[User:Pokrface|Pokrface]] 15: | Thanks for the welcome. The supposition that the interrogation drug would be off-loaded during the decommissioning is tied into the nature of the product. If it's a weapon--materiel, like chemical weapons--it would have been taken off along with the rest of the materiel. If it's classified as medical supplies, likely its fate would be the same as the other medical supplies, which apparently stay during decommissioning. Either way, though, you're right that it's pure speculation. --[[User:Pokrface|Pokrface]], 15:39, 31 Jan 2007 (CST) | ||