Talk:The Farm/Archive 1: Difference between revisions

Discussion page of The Farm/Archive 1
Line 22: Line 22:
:I am sorry for making that work for you, and I am sorry that I'm not registered. Goin to register, right now. I like it here. Pavel "Lordhp" Ptacek --[[User:83.208.88.147|83.208.88.147]] 13:41, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
:I am sorry for making that work for you, and I am sorry that I'm not registered. Goin to register, right now. I like it here. Pavel "Lordhp" Ptacek --[[User:83.208.88.147|83.208.88.147]] 13:41, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
::Welcome, Pavel. We'll try to help out your contributions by fixing up any English errors as necessary. The idea that there was a real Sharon makes sense as other humans over time would have had to raise the orphan, which would create plenty of paperwork that would be hard to forge and plenty of humans that knew Sharon that would be harder to produce. We haven't been let in on the true origins of Sharon, however, so we'll have to leave that discussion here. Yep, it '''is''' a great site! [[User:Spencerian|Spencerian]] 17:23, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
::Welcome, Pavel. We'll try to help out your contributions by fixing up any English errors as necessary. The idea that there was a real Sharon makes sense as other humans over time would have had to raise the orphan, which would create plenty of paperwork that would be hard to forge and plenty of humans that knew Sharon that would be harder to produce. We haven't been let in on the true origins of Sharon, however, so we'll have to leave that discussion here. Yep, it '''is''' a great site! [[User:Spencerian|Spencerian]] 17:23, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
:::I'm the guy who put that in. It was based off a spoiler of the episode I found on a forum. I put it under my IP address (69.194.201.1)
:::I'm the guy who put that in. It was based off a spoiler of the episode I found on a forum. I put it under my IP address (69.194.201.1).[[User:Crazyrabbits|Crazyrabbits]] 15:10, 19 Aug 2005 (EDT)
[[User:Crazyrabbits|Crazyrabbits]] 15:10, 19 Aug 2005 (EDT)


== Simon's Quote to Starbuck ==
== Simon's Quote to Starbuck ==

Revision as of 19:10, 19 August 2005

Three more battlestars? Yeah, right. Kuralyov 21:47, 12 May 2005 (EDT)

fixed it

I have no idea where the "three battlestars" comment came from (with a full complement of vipers and crew??), but I replaced it with a more accurate sentence.

Question regarding Detailed Plot Information

May we have a source on the information entered in The Farm artice, particularly the stuff regarding the detailed plot that was just added? Thanks! -- Joe Beaudoin 23:03, 17 Jul 2005 (EDT)

It's not new, I've seen it somewhere before a month or two back...I'll see if I can find what source I saw it in. Kuralyov 00:04, 18 Jul 2005 (EDT)

Boomer's Origins

A writer from 83.208.88.147 added what was an unfortunately mangled addition to the page regarding Galactica-Boomer's origins as well as a question on the farms' use. I don't believe the writer is a native English writer or speaker and it was difficult to interpret, much less edit at first. I paired down the question on how viable human embryos could be used, which was an insightful question. However, in a second element the writer suggested (I think) that Boomer may have been legitimately born by humans who were not Cylons but controlled by the Cylons. This flies in the face of what we do know of humano-Cylons.

Number Six, in the miniseries is genuinely surprised at the small frailty of a human baby, strongly suggesting that humano-Cylons are generated as a mature adult and never as adolescents. We know from this episode that Cylons can't biologically create life by gestation like humans, nor are they compatible at the genetic level without some help (in Helo's case, love). While the writer has a point that the Cylons may have placed their creations within the Colonies much earlier than 2 years prior to the events of the miniseries, we haven't any evidence as yet that supports this. All indications thus far suggest that the Cylon infiltration was a recent event. That doesn't mean that the Cylons didn't do their homework, since Boomer's life history apparently holds up to scrutiny from others and from Boomer herself. It should be noted that Boomer believed she was truly human and never had doubts until her nascent programming become more active and she began missing blocks of time. I hope I gleaned and rewrote the writer's thoughts appropriately in the areas where their contribution wasn't patently contradictory to the data we know. Spencerian 10:17, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Well said. --Peter Farago 11:23, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
You're right. I am not a natural english writer, so that some things are hard to explain for me. Wrong thing I did is that i have wrote it *into* the questions tab and *not* here. Deletion is good choice, as I see it.
Anyway, as you said, Boomer believed she is natural human. That what I wanted to say is the thing that we actually don't know how Boomer infiltrated army. There is possibility that she survived that accident what was noticed in mini-series. Cylons may used the accident as a cover for deploying new cylon agent - the Boomer. Their "parents" may died in that accident (it was a big explosion though) even with their true children. Boomer could be deployed then. I just didn't noticed this possibility.
I am sorry for making that work for you, and I am sorry that I'm not registered. Goin to register, right now. I like it here. Pavel "Lordhp" Ptacek --83.208.88.147 13:41, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
Welcome, Pavel. We'll try to help out your contributions by fixing up any English errors as necessary. The idea that there was a real Sharon makes sense as other humans over time would have had to raise the orphan, which would create plenty of paperwork that would be hard to forge and plenty of humans that knew Sharon that would be harder to produce. We haven't been let in on the true origins of Sharon, however, so we'll have to leave that discussion here. Yep, it is a great site! Spencerian 17:23, 16 Aug 2005 (EDT)
I'm the guy who put that in. It was based off a spoiler of the episode I found on a forum. I put it under my IP address (69.194.201.1).Crazyrabbits 15:10, 19 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Simon's Quote to Starbuck

for the quotes, the line by Simon, to Starbuck:

"Simon: Children of abusive parents often fear passing along that abuse to their own children."

on second viewing seems to be clearly talking about the Cylons, and how they view themselves.